Mafia - The story of Edgeville - Town Square

[Shiftey]

Also godfather appears as a villager affiliation Tyler. Palmar screwed up the rules I asked him to clarify that. So the description is wrong on that.

And yeah, given we had 10 villagers at start...

one is presumably a miller, that leaves 9
then one was a tracker (Ino) that leaves 8
we obviously assume there is a cop a doctor that leaves 6
then we have veteran and vigilante that leaves 4
now we have arches claiming to be a tracker that would leave only 3 villagers if there was a second vigilante that would mean only 2 villagers left, which would mean I am one of the two and that means everybody including another person is lying like fuck

that scenario sound very improbable and that makes me believe Arches may be lying about the whole tracker thing and that there are any additional blue roles (such as double vig)

[Nachmanun]

Yeah, makes enough sense, I guess the Ninja messaged Delling and Delling sortof made him use 1 kill...

For the first time in this game you've actually got me convinced over something Shiftey

[Tyler]

Totally agree on the dell sweet talking a ninja, bless him. It's by far the most likely explaination.

As for double tracker, well not that I don't think Arches is suspicious, because I do, I wouldn't be supprised if Palmar doubled up at least one blue role.

[Vorte]

Palmar did say on several occations that we should not try to read him, though..

Right now I'm quite confused, really..

[Tyler]

Well he would say that vorte, but we are still gonna try

I got your role wrong! You can only determine mafia/villager assocication. Scratch all that stuff about being able to see if people are lying by testing their roles

[Vorte]

Yeah, the game is built around the double posetives\negatives!

I'm mainly looking to figure out who the whore is now.. y'know, so we can call someone a whore.

[Shiftey]

I think we can call Tyler a whore! He may be framed but that's one out of 11. How come everybody assumes right away that Cwave framed Tyler? Great play from Tyler how he managed to make you all believe that without any doubts or questions around that.

[Archz]

Not that clear about the rules, but Cwave could have framed Tyler before he got whacked of?

[Vorte]

Not that clear about the rules, but Cwave could have framed Tyler before he got whacked of?

Yes, killing was last in the list of priorities Palmar gave us on irc.

[Shiftey]

Yes of course he could, I am not disputing that. But another 9 people could have been framed. 10% chance it was actually Tyler. 90% chance that it was someone else. So vorte's investigation may have been correct all along. Yet nobody seems to question that?

[Hugman]

Yes of course he could, I am not disputing that. But another 9 people could have been framed. 10% chance it was actually Tyler. 90% chance that it was someone else. So vorte's investigation may have been correct all along. Yet nobody seems to question that?

I love it how you present the data in a certain way in an attempt to convince us Shiftey.

Keep going, I find it amusing.

[Shiftey]

I find it amusing how badly you play this game if you are convince about a villager being a mafia Hugman. Apparently you are just as dumb as me, join the club.

Also if we believe vorte is the cop, and since noone else is posting and made the claim I can actually believe that.

Then how come when a cop comes outright and says I investigated this guy and he's mafia, everybody blames the villager?

Let vorte investigate me during next night and you'll see that I am a green villager.

[Tyler]

That is what they call specious resoning shiftey.

Of course Cwave would not have picked someone at random to frame. He would have chosen someone a)likley to be investigated and b)good for the mafia to be implicated. Personally I think I fit both those descriptions. I would put my chance at >50% for Cwave to frame.

There is however a 10% chance that I am a Miller

I agree with Hug here. We all know you are not this stupid. Please continue with the convincing.

[Shiftey]

We both know that the most obvious suspect for investigation was me at that point. And you know that so if anyone was framed there's a high chance it would be me cause I really stirred things up.

So your argument right there is not valid at all

Just like there is a chance TTaM was a miller and you had him lynched right? maybe maybe?

So Tyler is either just as dumb and terrible at this game like me and hugman now, or he's really smart mafia and everybody else is fucking dumb as fuck.

The only way to clean myself would be to break the rules and actually screenshot the PM but then I'd get modkilled.

But I seriously hate when people are stupid, that's what I hate most. And that's what you two are right now. Either that or very very clever mob creating a diversion from themselfs.

[Hugman]

We both know that the most obvious suspect for investigation was me at that point. And you know that so if anyone was framed there's a high chance it would be me cause I really stirred things up.

Annnnnnnnnnd there is the flaw in the logic.

The most obvious suspect for investigation at that point? Do you really believe that? Are you really that self involved?

Hands up if you felt that Shiftey was the most obvious suspect worthy of investigation at the end of day 2.