Mafia II - Story of the Iron Edge - Ship Deck

[Starbrow]

##Unvote: Delling

As he's sort of dead now...

[Starbrow]

##Unvote: Delling

HNNNNNGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG.......................

[Vdti]

I never defended TTaM as Shiftey pointed. I thought he was guiltly. This logic about talk to Kawe or else is retarded. I've given my reasons. It isn't just Kawe you are giving your name and role to it's his inner circle. While I agree Kawe is imperial I don't hold the same opinion of others.

I went back and looked, and it seems I'm mistaken for that. Sorry about it, must have confused you with someone else.

As when it comes to kawe giving our roles out to other players, all I can say is that I hope he uses the information we give him carefully, but I do believe he will use it wisely.

I have to say I'm very curious to see how the lynch of Delling went, but it doesn't really teach us anything if he was imperial. He claimed to a martyr, so if he's not either our martyr hasn't spoken up to incriminate him or we don't have one at all.

[Palmar]

##Lynch

The Captain had spoken. His words were few, but decisive.

"Bring me Delling".

"I will have you killed now, traitor. For your crimes against the Empire you shall die this day. Consider yourself lucky you won't be brought to Lord Vader in person.

Take him away!"

Roughly, Delling was dragged away in front of a firing squad of the Emperor's men, he pleaded his innocence until the moment the blasters fired.






Delling the Rebel Assassin has been killed

[shankski]

Good job el capitan.

[Chippen]

Thanks Emptyy, you confirmed it for me now

##Vote: Emptyy

Using a lynch on a target already pretty much lynched? GEGE

[Kendoki]

Good job indeed, i am going to a bbq tonight, not sure i be back on time to put in a vote, so gonna do it now. Here are my thoughts up to this point.

My list :

Delling for the reason mentioned earlier, seeing he is dead (good riddance), no need to vote anymore.

Chippen for strange voting, first fun, then joining the bandwagon then for starting the bandwagon, has given no info at all, or thoughts behind anything, just following along.

Blackwhale, not said a word, not seen anywhere, voting also bit weird no reasons anywhere, basicly the most usefull

Shankski rlly defensive post... rll weird, rlly suspicious.

Been a close call between Chippen and Shankski, but going for Shankski now.

So : ##Vote: Shankski

[shankski]

If I defend myself it looks guilty, if I don't defend myself it looks guilty.

You are making a mistake.

[Shiftey]

I would like to thank Tyler for making this kill happen. We pushed for it hard and despite the obstruction, we made it happen.

Congratulations

FOR THE EMPIRE!

[Vorte]

Said it on irc, anyway - Chippen:

I do not follow your logic, there was alot of pressure to fire off dell, and it was obviously a great call - but for THAT REASON you now have MORE suspicion towards him? It shouldn't change anything, nobody suggested he were to kill Shiftey(I think? Correct me if I'm wrong).

[15:47] <Chippen> if emptyy really wanted to clear his name, he'd lynch shiftey (and shiftey was a rebel)

If I follow your logic, tyler should now be my main suspicion, which he's really, really not.

[Doomslay]

I think Emptyy lynching dell when he has that many votes is not only suspicious but a waste. Now we know dell was a rebel it would have been interesting to see who came out of the woodwork near lynching time to defend him. (now they don't have too).

Tyler was overly pushy towards the death of delling (even though it was already coming) this is an easily achievable ploy in acting innocent, atleast in my eye's.

(Going out later today so I'll try and catch up the rest tonight)

##Unvote: Delling
##Vote: Tyler

[Starbrow]

Note that this should not clear Emptyy, as there is still the possibility that Emptyy is a rebel and the Delling lynch was an attempt to mark him as a trustworthy Imperial. Sure we're down a rebel, which is great, but it does not mean he is immune. Remember this everyone. And no offense meant Emptyy, we just gotta play it safe!

Tyler pushing for the kill is good, but the same logic applies, he is not a proven Imperial for that feat alone.

I'm thinking of voting for Shankski untill he sorts out the utter mess of his last role post, or talks to Kawe, or at least provides an argument that makes sense. Alternatively we heard that Shiftey knew about TTaMs role in all of this, and someone certainly leaked it to the rebels it seems.

Time to get some theories on the table as to what we can conclude from delling being a rebel!

[Tyler]

So with the amount of players left we now have around 25% chance of lynching a rebel.
It seems there is a general consensus that either shiftey or emptyy is a rebel.
Why not vote for a 50/50 chance instead of a 25% chance?

I dont quite see what delling did that was so suspicious tbh. Intrinsic was a logical choice imho. As mentioned earlier I did not see any of the main suspects as rebels and atleast it is confirmed that ttam was innocent.

These two quotes are the reason I'm going to vote for Grax. He has not done anything contructive this game. Just tried to provoke me (and Eet) into pointless personal arguments. If he were imperial he would be trying to smooth the waters, not carry over arguments from last game.

##Vote: Graxlos

p.s. Thanks you too Shiftey. WP!

[Vdti]

Just noticed the bot differentiates between shankski and Shankski, so just revoting:

##Unvote: shankski
##Vote: Shankski

As for delling being a rebel, I'm a bit surprised that our martyr didn't speak up when delling claimed to be one. (If we have one).

[kawe]

If I defend myself it looks guilty, if I don't defend myself it looks guilty.

You are making a mistake.

If it was a defense, it was full of holes and big inconsistancies, as pointed out by Starbrow

Why on earth would you trust 2/3 other people enough to tell your role, but Kawe (the only one we have any inkling of evidence is imperial) you do not trust? And who then knows your role? Does it even make sense that you're telling other people your role when you in the same post claim to be a green?

In fact, didn't you just manage to show everyone that you are in fact NOT a green?

*Honks down and waits for some admin to let us know what Delling was*

And which instead of addressing, you make an emo "I can't win" post.