Mafia II - Story of the Iron Edge - Ship Deck

[Starbrow]

... Aaaafter I correct that it was Kawe who switched to delling, not Ino. Really should get some sort of script for this.

[Chippen]

love that intense voting towards the end there

[Tyler]

The first point I want to make it that not posting is bad mkay. Not only is it the easiest way for scum to hide, it is the easiest excuse the mob have got to bandwagon someone.

However this does not mean you need to spam the thread. The only thing worse than not posting is posting lots, but saying nothing. If you say nothing useful then the empire cannot check for consistency and you make the thread less managable. In fact you are likley to hide useful information.

This is why Delling has been the worst poster so far 70+ posts, no real content. The only post of any value was "Lynch Intrinsic", and that was far too long to essentially say "He hasn't posted anything useful". This is why he is number one suspect.

Now Emptty, there is something amazingly sinister about this quote

As your Captain, I do not appreciate sneaking and speaking during the night. We all need our clear thinking for the morning if we ought to figure out who amongst us are rebels.

On a serious note: ...

I know that it finished with "On a serious note", but it didn't really take the edge off it for me. As the first post after lynching an innocent I would have thought that a little contrition would have been in order.

An other thing is that presenting your vote for Intrisic as a chioce between him and TTaM is what they call a false dichotomy. You could have voted for Delling, who as I have pointed out, is doing worse than not posting. Now you may disagree with me on that, but you do need to justify yourself. Finally my point about the bandwagon was: you spotted a bandwagon forming for Tronz but didn't see the bigger one for Intrinsic? That is beyond ironic imo.

Mouseh, I am going to point out again for those not on IRC that my biggest mistake last game was thinking there is no way that all 5 mafia had voted for Vorte. This condemmed Grax in my eyes and lost us the game. We should not rule Delling out because we think "There is no way they would make such a dumb play". That would be very silly.

More sage advice I read somewhere was "Never attribute to stupidity what you can to malice".

[delling2]

In my defence (and I'll say more once the new day actually begins!), a lot of my posts were on the first day, which was a bank holiday. You'll see that I posted a lot less on the next day.

I'm not trying to defend the fact that I have possibly obscured the action of Rebels -- I admit, that's poor form on my behalf -- I'm just trying to explain that it wasn't my _intention_.

After watching the last game, the main take-away seemed to be "post more!", and I was just trying to do that. I'm a quick learner though, and now I've slowed down, and I like to think that most of my posts since the second day are of higher quality.

FWIW, I'd also like to know about this 'inconsistency' thing is. Shiftey (I think?) says I'm being inconsistent. I'm not sure what that means. I'm well aware that I haven't added much actual content to the discussion -- but if I haven't said much, how can I be inconsistent? It's not like I've been saying 'omg lynch X!' 'actually I take it back, lynch Y!' I made a case for lynching Intrinsic (instead of Kesh or Kawe), and stuck with it. I still maintain that lynching Intrinsic was better than lynching Kesh or Kawe.

And now I'm going to 'go to sleep' and hope that I, and the rest of this fair ship, make it through the night!

[Palmar]

Remember to send in your night actions, or confirm that you're not using them.

[Yoica]

So some interesting things and conclusions are being drawn today I see. I just came back and I'm off to bed soon but there is 1 thing I want to say quickly before doing more analysis tmw.

People are tripping over Emptyy's post after the lynching. While not worded very well, isn't the gist of it something any proper captain should say? Also do you really believe any player with an night action will listen it? Just a bit of RP that missed the mark imo. (His vote change to Intrinsic is something I haven't analyzed yet, but voting analysis isn't something I can do properly in ~15min)

[delling2]

FWIW -- I will be away from my computers between 5pm Friday and late'ish Sunday. I will be able to check in (smartphone, iPad), but I won't be in any position to hammer F5 for all the latest updates.

My girlfriend got posted on another Star Destroyer, you see, and I had to ask for a special leave of absence from our Glorious Captain -- but he consented! So I'm off to, er, fire my blaster.

[Palmar]

##Day

As the day shift returns to their positions after a stressful night, some of the crew are absent. After investigation it is clear that several members of the crew have been murdered during the night.





Ino the Private has been murdered
TTaM the Vice Admiral has been murdered
Nachmanun the Imperial Agent has been murdered

It is now day 2, it will end 23:59 on Saturday

[Shiftey]

##Vote: Delling

[shankski]

1 word..... FUCK

[kawe]

Sorry Nach.

[Gaeios(Graxlos)]

Epic fail. All you guys wanting to lynch ttam.

[Chippen]

After this gruesume night my resolve is steadfast

##Vote: Dellin

[Chippen]

Sigh

##Vote: Delling

[Sintrael]

God fucking dammit daekesh...